It appears that they are not exactly the same. They use the same resistance potentiometer (10k ohm) but use s different type of pole (the part the joystick caps connect to) which would make the interchangeable joystick caps no longer compatible. As long as you are comfortable with desoldering and soldering in a new analog stick you can go with the [link|https://www.amazon.com/dp/B07R5Q15B9?th=1|ElecGear EL4 analog stick replacements|new_window=true] available on Amazon.