MacBook turns off when charger is disconnected

Question

MacBook Pro 13" Unibody Mid 2012

모델 A1278, 2012년 6월 출시. Turbo Boost가있는 Intel 프로세서, 최대 512 MB DDR5 비디오 RAM

1623 질문 전체 보기

Henning Klepp Christensen @henchr

평판: 167

4

1

게시일: 2016년 11월 23일

옵션

MacBook turns off when charger is disconnected

Hi,

Around two days ago I was about to move my workhorse to the kitchen, to do some culinary research (read: how to boil potatoes) when my MacBook just turned off when I disconnected the charger. I've had this problem before, which went away after a short while by itself. I just pinned it down to magnets or magic. After a while of being mildly annoyed by it shutting down, I began testing the battery in TechTool, which gave me virtually no information save for the fact that the battery is just maintaining its charge, but not actually getting any.

The battery indicator shows a 100% charge, as does Coconut Battery, which should mean that it's not the SMC. I did an SMC and PRAM reset, though it's unclear if it did anything at all. I'll try an SMC bypass and see if that does anything at all and update on this.

Logic tells me that it's the I/O board which is fooling around, but given my current financial situation, I don't want it to be. So, bottom line, is there any way to be completely sure that it's due to the I/O board, and/or any good way to fix it? Any help will be very appreciated and will hopefully help others in the future too.

For the sake of clarity, I'll enclose two Coconut Battery screenshots for future reference.

답변되었습니다! 답변 보기 저도 같은 문제를 겪고 있습니다

좋은 질문 입니까?

예 아니요

점수 13

댓글 7개

Tried nothing worked for me

shivpal singh 의 2019년 2월 2일

I had this problem too. Tried everything this forum tells you.Finally what worked for me is that I took it to Apple service centre and all he did was to disconnect the battery from inside and reconnect it. Probably there was a loose connection of the Battery inside with the system. Thankfully it worked. I made an effort to come back here and mention this, as this was an easy solution and one may overlook this point.

suryakalaperi 의 2021년 3월 6일

Thank you for your response.

Did you mean all the battery system or just the connector? Because I tried to pull the connector and then push it strongly to avoid a loose connection, but it didn’t work. I didn’t try to remove the battery though.. If you tell me that removing all the battery system worked for you, I may give it a try..

Marco Schiavone 의 2021년 3월 7일

Hi, I have a similar issue. My Macbook air works when unplugged but suddenly crashes when it reaches about 80 percent. I never know when the crash will happen but I keep losing important stuff so this is annoying!

Keep Smiling 의 2020년 11월 3일

Exactly the same behavior, in my case caused by corrosion on the I/O Board. Cleaning with a toothbrush and Iso alcohol, the problem was solved.

Luis Andrés Pi Velasco 의 2018년 5월 19일

댓글 2개 더보기

댓글 달기

답변 2개

선택된 답변

Dan @danj

평판: 478.9k

Self employed contract worker

35

329

970

게시일: 2016년 11월 23일

옵션

I bet you leave your system plugged in most of the time.

What is happening here is SMC thinks the power level is below the set threshold so it needs to power down the system into deep sleep mode.

So how to fix? It's quite simple you need to do a SMC reset and cycle the battery a few times by fully discharging it and recharging it. That way the setpoint is memorized correctly.

Here's the Apple TN you'll need to reference: Reset the System Management Controller (SMC) on your Mac

The other method is disconnecting the Battery and pressing the Power button for 15 sec’s to fully discharge the logic board, then plug in the battery and MagSafe. The system should restart on its own.

And lastly, check your battery! Install this gem of an app! CoconutBattery take a snapshot of the apps main window and post it here for us to see 기존 질문에 이미지 추가하기

해당 답변은 도움이 되었습니까?

예 아니요

점수 3

댓글 14개:

I bet you didn't read my post in which I said I reset the SMC. As far as my battery goes, I try my best to not have it plugged in most of the time and give it a chance to fully empty out before plopping the charger back in. However, I did just open the MacBook up and tinkered with a few wires, which seemingly did nothing. Then I did an SMC bypass (unplugging the laptop, holding the power button for 10 secs, plugging the computer back in while holding the power button for an additional 10 secs and then releasing and pressing it again to get it to boot) which got it up and running without a charger plugged. From there, I just did yet another SMC reset, booted in safe mode, checked TechTool and everything looked positive - this time with a 0% charge (as opposed to the 100% charge reported earlier). No clue what caused the Mac to report a faulty battery/I/O board, but we're back to normal. Again we can nail this down to magnets and magic.

Henning Klepp Christensen 의 2016년 11월 23일

Did you pull the battery connection? Often I find I end up needing to do it that way to be effective. Pull the battery internally, press and hold the power button a good 2 minutes then plug the battery back in and restart.

No magic here and it's not magnets either :-) I confess I did skim your Q. It's a problem I've seen a few times so I had a strong idea what was up here.

Dan 의 2016년 11월 23일

You may want to clean the MagSafe connector pins and pads. The middle pin is how the charger and the system communicate. If the cord pins or the DC inboard contact pads are dirty or corroded you can have some charging issues. But given your coconut battery info I don't see this as your issue.

Dan 의 2016년 11월 23일

The Chicken and the Egg problem ;-}

The premise here is once SMC is reset it does not have either a high or low threshold set. So once done you need to completely drain the battery until SMC see's the low threshold voltage wise has been hit it will then shutdown. Now recharging the battery and then repeating will set the high point. That should do it!

Now the but! The voltage comparator logic on the logic board needs to be working properly. If SMC is prematurely shutting down after a reset there is a problem on the logic board. Often corrosion has built up on the one or more of the components that set the value or the chip its self is defective.

Dan 의 2017년 11월 27일

How did you solve the problem? I appreciate your help!

Rahel Muhamad 의 2019년 8월 25일

댓글 9개 더보기

댓글 달기

I had this problem too. Tried everything this forum tells you.Finally what worked for me is that I took it to Apple service centre and all he did was to disconnect the battery from inside and reconnect it. Probably there was a loose connection of the Battery inside with the system. Thankfully it worked. I made an effort to come back here and mention this, as this was an easy solution and one may overlook this point. — suryakalaperi
Thank you for your response.

Did you mean all the battery system or just the connector? Because I tried to pull the connector and then push it strongly to avoid a loose connection, but it didn’t work. I didn’t try to remove the battery though.. If you tell me that removing all the battery system worked for you, I may give it a try.. — Marco Schiavone
Hi, I have a similar issue. My Macbook air works when unplugged but suddenly crashes when it reaches about 80 percent. I never know when the crash will happen but I keep losing important stuff so this is annoying! — Keep Smiling
Exactly the same behavior, in my case caused by corrosion on the I/O Board. Cleaning with a toothbrush and Iso alcohol, the problem was solved. — Luis Andrés Pi Velasco
I bet you didn't read my post in which I said I reset the SMC. As far as my battery goes, I try my best to not have it plugged in most of the time and give it a chance to fully empty out before plopping the charger back in. However, I did just open the MacBook up and tinkered with a few wires, which seemingly did nothing. Then I did an SMC bypass (unplugging the laptop, holding the power button for 10 secs, plugging the computer back in while holding the power button for an additional 10 secs and then releasing and pressing it again to get it to boot) which got it up and running without a charger plugged. From there, I just did yet another SMC reset, booted in safe mode, checked TechTool and everything looked positive - this time with a 0% charge (as opposed to the 100% charge reported earlier). No clue what caused the Mac to report a faulty battery/I/O board, but we're back to normal. Again we can nail this down to magnets and magic. — Henning Klepp Christensen
Did you pull the battery connection? Often I find I end up needing to do it that way to be effective. Pull the battery internally, press and hold the power button a good 2 minutes then plug the battery back in and restart.

No magic here and it's not magnets either :-) I confess I did skim your Q. It's a problem I've seen a few times so I had a strong idea what was up here. — Dan
You may want to clean the MagSafe connector pins and pads. The middle pin is how the charger and the system communicate. If the cord pins or the DC inboard contact pads are dirty or corroded you can have some charging issues. But given your coconut battery info I don't see this as your issue. — Dan
The Chicken and the Egg problem ;-}

The premise here is once SMC is reset it does not have either a high or low threshold set. So once done you need to completely drain the battery until SMC see's the low threshold voltage wise has been hit it will then shutdown. Now recharging the battery and then repeating will set the high point. That should do it!

Now the but! The voltage comparator logic on the logic board needs to be working properly. If SMC is prematurely shutting down after a reset there is a problem on the logic board. Often corrosion has built up on the one or more of the components that set the value or the chip its self is defective. — Dan

Karen D'Souza @karendsouza 평판: 37 1 · Answer 1 · 2018-01-31T16:28:10-07:00

가장 유용한 답변

Karen D'Souza @karendsouza

평판: 37

1

게시일: 2018년 1월 31일

옵션

Hi, I might have a similar problem. My MacBook Pro shuts down suddenly sometimes when I move it and the charger gets disconnected. It doesn't always happen, so I'm sure that it's not a battery problem. It turned out it's a problem with my charger. Perhaps it sends some surges of electricity or is otherwise unsafe that the MacBook decides to shut down. Anyway, the problem seemed to have disappeared when I got a new charger.

해당 답변은 도움이 되었습니까?

예 아니요

점수 3

댓글 1개:

I agree, in most cases this is a charger issue, specifically the L tip magsafe cable. Since my original magsafe disintegrated, I have used numerous compatible adapters and they all develop this issue over time. When it starts to happen, I just get a new charger.

face 의 2018년 2월 2일

댓글 달기

MacBook Pro 13" Unibody Mid 2012

MacBook turns off when charger is disconnected

Update (11/23/2016)

답변 2개

귀하의 답변을 추가하세요