Will this machine power on with only one CPU?

Question

Mac Pro First Generation

Mac Pro First Generation는 Apple Inc.이 제조한 Intel Xeon-기반 워크 스테이션 컴퓨터입니다. 2006년부터 2008년까지의 컴퓨터가 1 세대 모델에 포함됩니다.

317 질문 전체 보기

[deleted] @deleted13882

평판: 21

1

게시일: 2017년 11월 11일

옵션

Will this machine power on with only one CPU?

I recently acquired a 2006 Mac Pro, which, according to the diagnostic LEDs on the logic board, has a fault on CPU B. I've tried replacing the thermal paste and checking all connections, but to no avail.

I've also tried removing the second CPU entirely, but this still doesn't work. The machine powers on and the fans spin up (the GPU fan in particular is rather loud), but nothing happens beyond that.

It may also be worth noting that when both CPUs are installed, the system will push out a video signal, though it's just a black screen. It appears to be restarting endlessly and encountering the same error. When only one CPU is installed no video signal is sent out.

Am I missing something, or can the Mac Pro only boot with both CPUs installed (I've even tried putting the heatsink back and plugging in the temp sensor)?

답변되었습니다! 답변 보기 저도 같은 문제를 겪고 있습니다

좋은 질문 입니까?

예 아니요

점수 0

댓글 2개

Have you tried reinstalling the OS? Something could be corrupt and preventing the system from starting properly.

Carlos Oulman 의 2017년 11월 12일

There's no hard drive in the system right now, but I can't even get far enough to attempt that if there was one. If something is corrupted it's within the computer's EFI, which can't be fixed with a simple OS reinstall.

[deleted] 의 2017년 11월 12일

댓글 달기

답변 1개

선택된 답변

mayer @mayer

평판: 685.2k

MacHale Enterprises

3.4k

1.1k

2.6k

게시일: 2017년 11월 12일

옵션

One of my 2008 Pros shipped with only one CPU. I believe all the 2006-2008 Pros shipped with two sockets even when only one CPU was present. I did do an upgrade from a single to dual on my Mac Pro "Quad Core" 2.8 (2008). I'm just thinking out loud here.

There was a fan syncing software program on the original system installation disk and it had to be used with any major tear down or you got run away fans. I would try booting from the original system installation disk. Let us know your results. Also that CPU should be dirt cheap.

On my 2008 I went from a 2.8 GHz Q. Core Xeon E5462, to a 3.0 GHz Q. Core Xeon E5472 x2 for under $75 and most of that expense was the additional heat sink.

Let us know what happens with the optical drive boot. You are going to have to have that original installation disk in any case. It can probably be found on eBay.

해당 답변은 도움이 되었습니까?

예 아니요

점수 2

댓글 2개:

Will do. I haven't found an original install disc but I've ordered a pair of Xeon 5160 CPUs. I've been trying other troubleshooting steps like resetting the SMC and PRAM (I can't get far enough to reset PRAM with the keyboard so I removed the CMOS battery), swapping out the video card/trying different slots, etc.

I can verify USB ports are receiving power, as the light on the mouse is lit when plugged in.

I've also tried booting the Firmware Restoration CD, but I can't even get far enough to do that (the system doesn't respond even after holding the power button as instructed).

One more thing, I've been looking at the diagnostic LEDs on the logic board while booting up. The LEDs for trickle power, GPU present and power on are lit as they should be, but LED 8 (EFI good) never comes on except for when the power button is first pressed, after which it immediately goes out and stays that way. If I'm not mistaken, the LED should light after a successful POST (when EFI is ready to hand control over to the OS).

[deleted] 의 2017년 11월 12일

Just got the new set of CPUs in. After installing them both, I powered up the machine. The power LED comes on and the fans spin, and I even get a faint chime. But the video signal is still blank and the chime repeats infinitely. The LED for a fault on CPU B is still lit. I tried resetting firmware; the power LED flashes and the long tone sounds, but the disc drive doesn't open and eventually the Mac just goes back to repeating the chime. Resetting SMC and PRAM have had no effect.

I tried one CPU again and got the same result as previously described: light on, fans spinning, but no video.

I tried both CPUs again but swapped, and still got the same CPU fault LED. This leads me to believe the second socket may be toast.

[deleted] 의 2017년 11월 16일

댓글 달기

Have you tried reinstalling the OS? Something could be corrupt and preventing the system from starting properly. — Carlos Oulman
There's no hard drive in the system right now, but I can't even get far enough to attempt that if there was one. If something is corrupted it's within the computer's EFI, which can't be fixed with a simple OS reinstall. — [deleted]
Will do. I haven't found an original install disc but I've ordered a pair of Xeon 5160 CPUs. I've been trying other troubleshooting steps like resetting the SMC and PRAM (I can't get far enough to reset PRAM with the keyboard so I removed the CMOS battery), swapping out the video card/trying different slots, etc.

I can verify USB ports are receiving power, as the light on the mouse is lit when plugged in.

I've also tried booting the Firmware Restoration CD, but I can't even get far enough to do that (the system doesn't respond even after holding the power button as instructed).

One more thing, I've been looking at the diagnostic LEDs on the logic board while booting up. The LEDs for trickle power, GPU present and power on are lit as they should be, but LED 8 (EFI good) never comes on except for when the power button is first pressed, after which it immediately goes out and stays that way. If I'm not mistaken, the LED should light after a successful POST (when EFI is ready to hand control over to the OS). — [deleted]
Just got the new set of CPUs in. After installing them both, I powered up the machine. The power LED comes on and the fans spin, and I even get a faint chime. But the video signal is still blank and the chime repeats infinitely. The LED for a fault on CPU B is still lit. I tried resetting firmware; the power LED flashes and the long tone sounds, but the disc drive doesn't open and eventually the Mac just goes back to repeating the chime. Resetting SMC and PRAM have had no effect.

I tried one CPU again and got the same result as previously described: light on, fans spinning, but no video.

I tried both CPUs again but swapped, and still got the same CPU fault LED. This leads me to believe the second socket may be toast. — [deleted]

Mac Pro First Generation

Will this machine power on with only one CPU?

답변 1개

귀하의 답변을 추가하세요