MacBook suddenly power off or freezes.

Question

MacBook Core 2 Duo

모델 A1181: 1.83, 2, 2.1, 2.13, 2.16, 2.2, 또는 2.4 GHz Core 2 Duo 프로세서

1203 질문 전체 보기

Robin Dieker @robindieker

평판: 51

4

5

게시일: 2012년 5월 20일

옵션

MacBook suddenly power off or freezes.

Hey,

just got a new MacBook on ebay, the seller already said that it freezes sometimes or restarts unexpected. But he doesn't know if its RAM or Logic Board.

I have 14 days returning policy by the way ;)

I switched RAM and HDD (there was a 320 Gig HD installed, used the old one from my "destroyed" MacBook (this time it worked and I checked the screws thousand times ;) ). But it still freezes randomly. Then I need to restart sometimes 9-10 times (mostly it freezes right after pressing power Button, the Optical Device (CD) doesn't try to spin up) and then it works for 2-3 hours, then it goes mad again. The seller hasn't explained that the CD Device is not working properly (I need to PUSH insert CDs, but they are ejecting well)...

Anyone can help me? Can it really be the LogicBoard? I mean what should be damaged? just a loose cable?

Or is it PRAM Battery wich is damaged or empty? It saves time when not on Power, but that and Resetting SMC mostly fixes (Or creates) the boot Problem

답변되었습니다! 답변 보기 저도 같은 문제를 겪고 있습니다

좋은 질문 입니까?

예 아니요

점수 -1

댓글 달기

답변 1개

선택된 답변

Parappaman @parappaman

평판: 119

4

2

1

게시일: 2012년 5월 20일

옵션

As you already tried swapping out the RAM, it could be anything from a bad motherboard to a faulty CPU/GPU. I'd check temperatures with iStat just to be sure it's not something related to a bad thermal paste application or faulty heatsink (heatpipes can leak and become useless if they have blemishes or have been bent), other than that, it might just be a dud. :-D

A dead PRAM battery will not cause any freeze during use, so I'd call that out.

해당 답변은 도움이 되었습니까?

예 아니요

점수 0

댓글 11개:

what do you mean with "dud" ? :D Checking temperatures now, they are about 54 degrees Celsius.

Robin Dieker 의 2012년 5월 20일

Okay, just started the MacBook and it shows a CPU1 Temperature of 50 degrees celsius - is that right?? Cant believe it. Was very cool and also feels very cool now

Robin Dieker 의 2012년 5월 20일

Here are some more Temps:

http://img7.imagebanana.com/img/r07s4y29...

(Recorded 5 minutes after turning on)

Robin Dieker 의 2012년 5월 20일

By "dud" I meant a faulty item. :)

Temperatures recorded the second time look very high on the CPU side as they've been taken just 5 minutes after a cold boot, were you heavily taxing the system? If not, I think we might have an answer. Try checking if the fan is spinning up properly and hot air is coming out of the back, as the vents could be clogged. If everything seems normal, get some thermal paste and reapply it to the heatsinks.

Anyway, if the price wasn't a bargain accordingly to the laptop's status, the patience and time involved in troubleshooting it might not be worth it, so do consider using the return policy by taking it back to the seller.

Parappaman 의 2012년 5월 21일

mhhm yeah it worked beautifully from yesterdays evening until half an hour ago. 9-10 restarts (even I paused 30 minutes between two restarts one time) now it seems to work again.

I got a kernel Panic but it seems it hasn't been logged in Console or /Library/Logs/Diag . . . saw something about "system check" but system auto restarted 2 seconds after it

Should I maybe try it with one RAM slot in use? Maybe its faulty RAM Slot (RAM changed already)

Robin Dieker 의 2012년 5월 21일

댓글 6개 더보기

댓글 달기

what do you mean with "dud" ? :D Checking temperatures now, they are about 54 degrees Celsius. — Robin Dieker
Okay, just started the MacBook and it shows a CPU1 Temperature of 50 degrees celsius - is that right?? Cant believe it. Was very cool and also feels very cool now — Robin Dieker
Here are some more Temps:

http://img7.imagebanana.com/img/r07s4y29...

(Recorded 5 minutes after turning on) — Robin Dieker
By "dud" I meant a faulty item. :)

Temperatures recorded the second time look very high on the CPU side as they've been taken just 5 minutes after a cold boot, were you heavily taxing the system? If not, I think we might have an answer. Try checking if the fan is spinning up properly and hot air is coming out of the back, as the vents could be clogged. If everything seems normal, get some thermal paste and reapply it to the heatsinks.

Anyway, if the price wasn't a bargain accordingly to the laptop's status, the patience and time involved in troubleshooting it might not be worth it, so do consider using the return policy by taking it back to the seller. — Parappaman
mhhm yeah it worked beautifully from yesterdays evening until half an hour ago. 9-10 restarts (even I paused 30 minutes between two restarts one time) now it seems to work again.

I got a kernel Panic but it seems it hasn't been logged in Console or /Library/Logs/Diag . . . saw something about "system check" but system auto restarted 2 seconds after it

Should I maybe try it with one RAM slot in use? Maybe its faulty RAM Slot (RAM changed already) — Robin Dieker

MacBook Core 2 Duo

MacBook suddenly power off or freezes.

답변 1개

귀하의 답변을 추가하세요