Replacement Battery Suddenly Drops from 40% to 20% after I reset SMC.

Question

MacBook Air 13" Early 2017

Apple은 MacBook Air 13"를 2017년 6월에 새로운 Broadwell Intel Core i5 프로세서로 업데이트하여 성능과 배터리 수명을 약간 향상시켰습니다.

423 질문 전체 보기

Spencer @spencerschmudde

평판: 11

1

게시일: 2024년 3월 27일

옵션

Replacement Battery Suddenly Drops from 40% to 20% after I reset SMC.

My MBA 2017 got a Service Recommended for the battery 2 months ago and I ordered a replacement battery off iFixIt. Once it arrived, I installed it without issue and calibrated it as instructed but the battery was dropping 1% every 2-3 minutes with just Safari open at half brightness. I tried resetting the SMC but it would then rapidly drop to below 20% from around 40% and would drain even faster after that. This continued for a few cycles so I contacted Support and they sent a new battery as they said it looked like a bad battery to them.

I installed the new battery a week ago when it arrived and did the calibration. It dropped at the same 1% every 2-3 minutes rate all the way from 100-0% and I decided to reset the SMC to see if that improved battery life. Unfortunately, the sudden drop from 40 to 20 problem reappeared. I reset the SMC again but the problem persists. Did I get another bad battery once from iFixIt? (Coconut Battery shown below for reference) Should I not have even touched the SMC? Should I re-calibrate the battery after the SMC reset? Any suggestions would be appreciated.

UPDATE: Per @danj 's request, here's CoconutBattery after it charged for 8 hours.

Here's CoconutBattery after 4 hours off being off the charger and not using the MacBook

Seems charging it to 100% and leaving it there for several hours did the trick as the battery did not suddenly drop at 40% and has held on with a steady discharge rate down to 25% as I write this now. I do wish the charge would last me longer (YouTube knocks off 1% every 1.5-2 minutes whereas Netflix and casual browsing on Safari gets me 3-4 minutes per percent point) but for a nearly 7 year old machine and third party battery replacement, I'll likely just have to deal with that and the 5 hours of screen time I've gotten in so far on this cycle is still longer than most Windows laptops last on battery.

One other thing I didn't mention initially is that after calibration I was only charging back up to 70-80% as I read that lithium-ion battery health is best preserved between cycles of 20-80%. That is also when the issue started so I'm now leaning towards that being the culprit instead of the SMC. Thanks @danj for your help!

답변되었습니다! 답변 보기 저도 같은 문제를 겪고 있습니다

좋은 질문 입니까?

예 아니요

점수 0

댓글 달기

답변 1개

선택된 답변

Dan @danj

평판: 479.4k

Self employed contract worker

35

329

971

게시일: 2024년 3월 27일

옵션

What are you using for a charger and cable?

Looking at CoconutBattery shows the battery is charging, just not fully charged with a somewhat high temp.

Let it charge a good 8 hours, take a fresh snapshot, then if you can, don’t use the system for four hours, then take one more snapshot. Posting then here so we can see.

해당 답변은 도움이 되었습니까?

예 아니요

점수 1

댓글 5개:

I'm using a 45W MagSafe 2 from Apple. My original that came with the Mac stopped working in October so this one isn't that old. Should I leave it plugged in for 8 hours once it hits 100% or just 8 hours plugged in even if part of that is while it's actually charging up to 100?

Spencer 의 2024년 3월 27일

@spencerschmudde - The battery should be fully charged after 8 hours. When you run CoconutBattery you should see that. Then shutting down the system with the charger disconnected should stay at this level of charge for 4 hours. I’m trying to see if we have a partial short which is running down the battery.

Dan 의 2024년 3월 27일

@danj - Gotcha. Thanks for clarifying. Both battery screenshots are up now.

Spencer 의 2024년 3월 28일

@spencerschmudde - Well the battery appears to be holding its charge. I assume you are using the system now is it running OK now?

Dan 의 2024년 3월 28일

@danj - It seems fine for now. I’ll use it as normal and see if it suddenly drops when it gets around 40% again. Hopefully it doesn’t. Will update later.

Spencer 의 2024년 3월 28일

댓글 달기

I'm using a 45W MagSafe 2 from Apple. My original that came with the Mac stopped working in October so this one isn't that old. Should I leave it plugged in for 8 hours once it hits 100% or just 8 hours plugged in even if part of that is while it's actually charging up to 100? — Spencer
@spencerschmudde - The battery should be fully charged after 8 hours. When you run CoconutBattery you should see that. Then shutting down the system with the charger disconnected should stay at this level of charge for 4 hours. I’m trying to see if we have a partial short which is running down the battery. — Dan
@danj - Gotcha. Thanks for clarifying. Both battery screenshots are up now. — Spencer
@spencerschmudde - Well the battery appears to be holding its charge. I assume you are using the system now is it running OK now? — Dan
@danj - It seems fine for now. I’ll use it as normal and see if it suddenly drops when it gets around 40% again. Hopefully it doesn’t. Will update later. — Spencer

MacBook Air 13" Early 2017

Replacement Battery Suddenly Drops from 40% to 20% after I reset SMC.

Update (03/27/24)

Update (03/28/24)

Update (03/29/24)

답변 1개

귀하의 답변을 추가하세요