주요 콘텐츠로 건너뛰기

노트북 컴퓨터 평가 방법

우리 모두는 소유하고 있는 기기들의 수리가 더욱 수월하기 원합니다—결국, 수리 용이성은 기기 수명과 의미가 같습니다. 우리는 모든 기기가 10점을 받기를 바라지만, 단지 몇 개만 성공할 것입니다. 무엇이 수리 용이한 기기를 만드냐고요?

우선, 기기 열기 어려움에 따라서 점수를 깎습니다. 기기를 열 수 없다면, 어떻게 수리를 하겠습니까? 일단 내부에 진입하면, 어떤 패스너를 사용했는지 주목합니다. 특허 나사 또는 접착제? 싫다 싫어! 십자 나사? 훨씬 낫네요!

우리가 계속해서 기기 내부를 살펴볼수록, 교체하기 쉬운 모듈식 부품, 자주 교체하는 부품 중심의 접근성, 그리고 개선 가능성은 우리를 미소를 짓게 하고 점수판에 점수를 추가합니다. 마지막으로, 완벽한 10점을 얻으려면, 제조사에서 제공하는 기기 무료 수리 설명서도 있어야 합니다.

어떤 기기들이 우리 수리인들의 승인을 받았을까요? 자사의 노트북 수리 점수 목록을 아래에서 확인하고, 여러 제품 추천을 원한다면 스마트폰 수리 점수, 그리고 태블릿 수리 점수를 확인하세요.

정렬 기준: 릴리즈 | 점수

Lenovo ThinkPad T14 Gen 3
  • 대부분의 수리는 매우 간단하며 기본 도구만 필요합니다.
  • 키보드 교체 절차는 업계 최고입니다.
  • 부분 납땜된 메모리 및 I/O 포트는 특정 수리를 까다롭게 합니다.

7

Framework Laptop
  • Every important component in the laptop is easy to access and replace.
  • Inside the laptop, most components are helpfully labeled to help orient and guide the fixer.
  • The Framework Laptop repair guides are free and easily accessible, and Framework is already selling spare parts right on their website.

10

HP EliteBook 840 Aero G8
  • RAM, SSD, 배터리 및 디스플레이는 높은 우선 순위, 접근이 쉬우며 빠르게 분리할 수 있습니다.
  • 스피커, 터치패드, 그리고 팬을 포함한 거의 모든 움직이는 부품들은 모듈식이며 모두 독립적 교체가 가능합니다.
  • 많은 케이블은 손상하기 쉬운 ZIF 커넥터를 사용합니다.

9

HP EliteBook 840 G7
  • The RAM, SSD, battery, and display are easily accessible and removable.
  • Almost all moving parts, including the speakers, trackpad, and fan are modular and can be independently replaced.
  • All screws are Phillips, and many are identical, preventing damage from accidental misplacement.

9

HP EliteBook x360 830 G7
  • The battery, SSD, RAM, and display are easily accessible and removable.
  • Almost all moving parts, including the speakers, trackpad, and fan are modular and can be independently replaced.
  • All screws are standard Phillips and Torx, and many are identical, preventing damage from accidental misplacement.

9

HP EliteBook 850 G5
  • RAM, SSD, and battery are easily accessible and removable.
  • All moving parts, including keyboard, trackpad, and pointing stick are modular and can be independently replaced.
  • The display can be quickly and independently replaced without any unnecessary disassembly.

10

HP ProBook 440 G7
  • The RAM, SSD, battery, and display are easily accessible and removable.
  • Almost all moving parts, including the HDD, trackpad, and fan are modular and can be independently replaced.
  • All screws are standard Phillips and Torx.

9

HP Elitebook x360 1040 G5
  • SSD and battery are easily accessible and removable.
  • Manufacturer provides free user-accessible repair documentation.
  • The device relies heavily on tapes, adhesives and fragile clips to secure components, complicating repairs.

6

MacBook Pro 16" 2019
  • 작은 부품은 모듈식이지만 프로세서, RAM, 그리고 플래시 메모리는 로직 보드에 납땜되어 있습니다.
  • 접착제 및/또는 리벳은 키보드, 배터리, 스피커 및 Touch Bar를 고정하므로 이런 부품 수리를 까다롭게 합니다.
  • Touch ID 센서는 전원 스위치이며 로직 보드에 고정되어 있어서 수리가 매우 복잡합니다.

1

Microsoft Surface Laptop 3 15"
  • The firmly glued-down battery will be very difficult to service when it inevitably goes kaput.
  • Torx Plus screws call for relatively rare drivers, but our standard Torx drivers worked in a pinch.
  • The opening procedure is straightforward, with a clever design that represents a dramatic improvement over its predecessors.

5

MacBook Pro 13" Two Thunderbolt Ports 2019
  • 독점 pentalobe/펜타로브/별나사는 계속 수리에 적대적입니다.
  • 배터리 어셈블리는 여전히 케이스에 매우 단단히 접착되어 있어서 소모품 교체를 복잡하게 합니다.
  • 납땜된 RAM은 업그레이드 가능성과 수명을 제한합니다.

2

HP EliteBook x360 830 G5
  • SSD, RAM, and battery are accessible and removable.
  • Manufacturer provides free user-accessible repair documentation.
  • All screws are standard Phillips and Torx.

9

HP EliteBook 840 G6
  • The RAM, SSD, and battery are easily accessible and removable.
  • All moving parts, including keyboard, trackpad, and pointing stick are modular and can be independently replaced.
  • The display can be quickly and independently replaced without any unnecessary disassembly.

10

HP EliteBook 830 x360 G6
  • SSD, RAM, and battery are accessible and removable.
  • Manufacturer provides free user-accessible repair documentation.
  • All screws are standard Phillips and Torx.

9

MacBook Pro 15" Touch Bar 2019
  • The processor, RAM, and flash memory are soldered to the logic board. Repairs and upgrades will be impractical at best.
  • The top case assembly, including the keyboard, battery, speakers, and Touch Bar, is glued together—making all those components impractical to replace separately.
  • The Touch ID sensor doubles as the power switch, and is paired with the T2 chip on the logic board. Fixing a broken power switch may require help from Apple, or a new logic board.

1

HP EliteBook 1050 G1
  • RAM, SSD, and battery are easily accessible and removable.
  • All screws are standard Phillips and Torx.
  • Manufacturer provides free user-accessible repair documentation.

9

MacBook Air 13” Retina Display Late 2018
  • The keyboard is integrated into the top case, requiring a full teardown for service.
  • Soldered, non-serviceable, non-upgradeable storage and RAM is a serious bummer on a $1,200+ laptop.
  • Many components are modular and straightforward to access—including the ports, fan, and speakers.

3

MacBook Pro 15" Touch Bar 2018
  • The processor, RAM, and flash memory are soldered to the logic board. Repairs and upgrades will be impractical at best.
  • The top case assembly, which includes the keyboard, battery, and speakers, is firmly glued in place—making all those components hard to replace separately.
  • The Touch ID sensor doubles as the power switch, and is paired with the T2 chip on the logic board. Fixing a broken power switch may require help from Apple, or a new logic board.

1

MacBook Pro 13" Touch Bar 2018
  • 프로세서, RAM, 그리고 플래시 메모리는 로직 보드에 납땜되어 있습니다. 수리 및 업그레이드는 기껏해야 비실용적입니다.
  • 키보드, 배터리 및 스피커를 포함하는 상단 케이스 어셈블리는 서로 접착되어 있으므로—이 모든 부품을 개별적으로 교체하는 것은 비현실적입니다.
  • Touch ID 센서는 전원 스위치 역할을 겸하며 로직 보드의 T2 칩과 페어되어 있습니다. 고장난 전원 스위치를 수리하려면 Apple의 도움 또는 새 로직 보드가 필요할 수 있습니다.

1

HP EliteBook 840 G3
  • RAM, SSD, and battery are easily accessible and removable.
  • All moving parts, including keyboard, trackpad, and pointing stick are modular and can be quickly replaced.
  • The display is immediately replaceable, without any unnecessary disassembly.

10

Dell Latitude E5270
  • All commonly failing (battery, trackpad buttons, display, keyboard) and upgradable (RAM, SSD) parts are easy to access and replace.
  • Minimal adhesive is used throughout the unit's construction. All fasteners are standard Phillips screws.
  • Overall construction is slightly complicated, but the manufacturer offers clear repair and disassembly instructions.

10

LG Gram 15"
  • Most components are immediately accessible after removing the lower case cover.
  • RAM and SSD are user-replaceable and parts for upgrades are readily accessible.
  • Battery is also user-replaceable.

9

Samsung Series 9 15"
  • All screws are Phillips screws.
  • RAM, SSD, and battery are all easily replaced.
  • Relatively flat, modular design means that most components can be replaced quickly without having to remove other obstructions.

9

Acer Predator 17.3"
  • A single latch releases the optical drive—no tools required.
  • A single panel gives access to the SSD, HDD, and two RAM slots.
  • The keyboard is not readily serviceable.

8

Dell XPS 13
  • Manufacturer provides free manuals online.
  • Once you manage to take off the bottom cover, all the parts are pretty easily replaceable.
  • Soldered RAM means you'll never be able to upgrade when things get slow.

7

MacBook Pro 13" Touch Bar 2017
  • 독점 pentalobe/펜타로브/별나사는 여전히 기기 열기를 불필요하게 어렵도록 합니다.
  • 배터리 어셈블리는 이제 완전히 그리고 매우 견고하게 케이스에 접착되어 교체를 어렵게 합니다.
  • 프로세서, RAM 그리고 플래시 메모리는 로직 보드에 납땜되어 있습니다.

1

Retina MacBook 2017
  • The processor, RAM, and flash memory are still soldered to the logic board.
  • A large amount of strong adhesive holds the battery assembly to the lower case .
  • The Retina display is a fused unit with no separate, protective glass. If the display is damaged, it'll be arduous and expensive to repair.

1

MacBook Pro 15" Touch Bar Late 2016
  • Use of proprietary pentalobe screws makes servicing and repair unnecessarily difficult.
  • The entire battery assembly is strongly glued into the case, complicating replacement.
  • The processor, RAM, and flash memory are soldered to the logic board.

1

MacBook Pro 13" Touch Bar Late 2016
  • 독점 pentalobe/펜타로브/별나사는 여전히 기기 열기를 불필요하게 어렵도록 합니다.
  • 배터리 어셈블리는 이제 완전히 그리고 매우 견고하게 케이스에 접착되어 교체를 어렵게 합니다.
  • 프로세서, RAM 그리고 플래시 메모리는 로직 보드에 납땜되어 있습니다.

1

MacBook Pro 13" Function Keys Late 2016
  • 독점 pentalobe/펜타로브/별나사는 여전히 기기 열기를 불필요하게 어렵도록 합니다.
  • 배터리 어셈블리는 이제 완전히 그리고 매우 견고하게 케이스에 접착되어 교체를 어렵게 합니다.
  • RAM은 로직 보드에 납땜되어 있습니다. 업그레이드 비용을 지금 지불하거나, 영원히 8GB로 남습니다. 업그레이는 불가능합니다.

2

Retina MacBook 2016
  • The processor, RAM, and flash memory are still soldered to the logic board.
  • The battery assembly remains entirely, and very solidly, glued into the lower case.
  • The Retina display is still a fused unit with no separate, protective glass. If the display needs replacing, it'll cost a pretty penny.

1

Asus Chromebook C202
  • Intuitive, uncomplicated design makes disassembly straightforward and reversible.
  • Modular components means many repairs can be carried out by quickly swapping a failed part.
  • Only Phillips #1 and #00 screws are used.

9

Retina MacBook 2015
  • Proprietary pentalobe screws continue to make opening the device unnecessarily difficult, and new cable routing makes the procedure even trickier.
  • The USB-C port is secured by tri-wing screws, and buried under the display brackets, complicating replacement. Also, being the only port, it will experience more use and wear than a typical single-purpose port.
  • The battery assembly is entirely, and very solidly, glued into the lower case.

1

MacBook Pro 13" Retina Display Early 2015
  • 독점 pentalobe/펜타로브/별나사는 여전히 기기 열기를 불필요하게 어렵도록 합니다.
  • 배터리 어셈블리는 이제 완전히 그리고 매우 견고하게 케이스에 접착되어 교체를 어렵게 합니다. 게다가 배터리는 이제 트랙 패드를 고정하는 나사와 케이블을 덮고 습니다. 배터리를 먼저 분리하지 않고는 트랙 패드 교체가 불가능 합니다.
  • Retina 디스플레이는 보호 유리가 없는 장치와 융합되어 있습니다. 디스플레이 내부에 고장이 나면 전체 ($$$) 어셈블리를 교체해야 합니다.

1

MacBook Air 13" Early 2015
  • Proprietary screws on the case require the right screwdriver.
  • All the components—including RAM and SSD—are proprietary.
  • Once you manage to take off the bottom cover, all the parts are pretty easily replaceable.

4

MacBook Air 11" Early 2015
  • The outer case is held on with Apple's proprietary Pentalobe screws, so you'll need the right screwdriver to get inside.
  • Just like the screws, all the components—including the RAM and SSD—are proprietary, making replacement parts more difficult to source.
  • Once you get past the outer case, all the major components are fairly easy to access for replacement.

4

MacBook Pro 13" Retina Display Late 2013
  • 독점 pentalobe/펜타로브/별나사는 여전히 기기 열기를 불필요하게 어렵도록 합니다.
  • 배터리 어셈블리는 이제 완전히 그리고 매우 견고하게 케이스에 접착되어 교체를 어렵게 합니다. 게다가 배터리는 이제 트랙 패드를 고정하는 나사와 케이블을 덮고 습니다. 배터리를 먼저 분리하지 않고는 트랙 패드 교체가 불가능 합니다.
  • Retina 디스플레이는 보호 유리가 없는 장치와 융합되어 있습니다. 디스플레이 내부에 고장이 나면 전체 ($$$) 어셈블리를 교체해야 합니다.

1

MacBook Pro 15" Retina Display Late 2013
  • Proprietary pentalobe screws prevent you from gaining access to anything inside.
  • As in the MacBook Air, the RAM is soldered to the logic board. Max out at 16GB now, or forever hold your peace—you can't upgrade.
  • The proprietary SSD has changed to a PCIe format, but still isn't a standard 2.5" drive. However, it is a separate daughtercard, and we’re hopeful we can offer an upgrade in the near future.

1

MacBook Air 11" Mid 2013
  • The outer case is held on with Apple's proprietary Pentalobe screws, so you'll need the right screwdriver to get inside.
  • Just like the screws, all the components—including the RAM and SSD—are proprietary, making replacement parts more difficult to source.
  • Once you get past the outer case, all the major components are fairly easy to access for replacement.

4

MacBook Air 13" Mid 2013
  • Proprietary screws on the case require the right screwdriver.
  • All the components—including RAM and SSD—are proprietary.
  • Once you manage to take off the bottom cover, all the parts are pretty easily replaceable.

4

Dell Inspiron Duo
  • Much of the internal hardware is not only user-replaceable, but is also easy purchased from Dell or a third party vendor.
  • Almost the entire computer can be taken apart with a plastic opening tool (or two) and a Phillips #0 screwdriver.
  • You have to remove the top case to access the battery, which is shameful for a Dell product.

7

MacBook Pro 13" Retina Display Late 2012
  • 배터리는 여전히 노트북 상단 케이스에 붙어 있지만 15” 모델 보다는 분리하기가 조금 쉽습니다.
  • 독점 pentalobe/펜타로브/별나사는 내부로 접근하지 못하게 합니다.
  • RAM은 로직 보드에 표면-실장 납땜되어 있어서 업그레이드할 수 없습니다. 8GB RAM은 영원합니다.

2

Asus Zenbook UX32VD
  • All the components are easy to access, with no proprietary screws inhibiting access.
  • The battery is not glued in place, and a person equipped with the right tools can replace it in a matter of minutes.
  • A lot of components were held in place with more adhesive than is necessary.

8

MacBook Pro 15" Unibody Mid 2012
  • Easily removable bottom panel and readily accessible battery, optical drive, hard drive, fans, and RAM.
  • Standard screws were used for all components, save for the battery.
  • Tri-wing screws on the battery require a specialty driver that an average user may not have.

7

MacBook Pro 15" Retina Display Mid 2012
  • Proprietary pentalobe screws prevent you from gaining access to anything inside.
  • As in the MacBook Air, the RAM is soldered to the logic board. Max out at 16GB now, or forever hold your peace—you can't upgrade.
  • The proprietary SSD isn't upgradeable either (yet), as it is similar but not identical to the one in the Air. It is a separate daughtercard, and we’re hopeful we can offer an upgrade in the near future.

1

MacBook Air 13" Mid 2012
  • Proprietary screws on the case require the right screwdriver.
  • All the components—including RAM and SSD—are proprietary.
  • Once you manage to take off the bottom cover, all the parts are pretty easily replaceable.

4

MacBook Air 13" Mid 2011
  • Opening the bottom cover is quite difficult if you don't have the right screwdriver. It's clear that Apple didn't want people to open their machine.
  • All the components -- including RAM and SSD -- are proprietary, meaning that no off-the-shelf parts will work in it without serious rigging.
  • Once you manage to take off the bottom cover, all the parts are pretty easily replaceable.

4

MacBook Pro 15" Unibody Early 2011
  • Easily removable bottom panel and readily accessible battery connector allow for easy repair of most components without touching the battery screws.
  • Unibody design allows for easy access of most components with minimal amounts of extra work needed to get to them.
  • Tri-wing screws limit the average person from replacing their own battery.

7

MacBook Air 11" Late 2010
  • Opening the bottom cover is quite difficult if you don't have the right screwdriver. It's clear that Apple didn't want people to open their machine.
  • All the components -- including RAM and hard drive -- are proprietary, meaning that no off-the-shelf parts will work in it without serious rigging.
  • Once you manage to take off the bottom cover, all the parts are pretty easily replaceable.

4