Somehow I managed to get the digitizer screen off but the black frame and lcd screen didn't come with it. It was all supposed to come off in one piece. I guess I wasn't going deep enough. I simply used the metal flathead tool to remove the black frame/lcd out. No wonder why it looked different!
How do the plastic volume buttons on the frame stay in place? I had to transfer them over. Each one removed easily. They go in fine on the new screen but fall out easily.